
Our elections have two parts — the primary election and the general election.
The primary is where candidates of the same party run against each other. Then the chosen candidates of each party compete in the general election.
After May, Libertarians and independent candidates can file to run in the general election as well. In May, the Republicans picked Jerry Smith over the judge currently seated. The Democrats did not have a candidate.
In this general election, we have two individuals who have filed after the primary as Libertarians. They have a strong voting record in the primaries as Republicans, including this year.
So why are they running as Libertarians? Are they truly Libertarians? The Libertarian candidate for a township board was caucused in as a Republican two years ago. Had he been upfront and said he was a Libertarian, do you think a group of Republican leaders would have chosen him? Neither of these candidates has ever proclaimed to be a Libertarian prior to May, and both want to downplay the Libertarian platform that they pretend to be supporting.
It seems, instead, neither was happy with the primary outcome, and they found a loophole to get on the ballot.
But again why? The Libertarian judge candidate supporters are saying that we need experience over party. Neither candidate for judge has been a judge before. So where were these “experience over party” people in the primary? If that is what they wanted, why did they not pick the seated judge with experience?
Based on the Libertarian judge candidate’s voting record, he would have been a good primary Republican candidate. So why run now as a Libertarian? Does he truly believe in experience over party? Again, that choice was an option in the primary. Or does he now see a loophole in the system and is using that to get the job?
The Republican Party and the Democratic Party have central committees. These are made up of precinct committeeman and an executive committee. You elect a precinct committeeman for your area of the township. They are elected to represent you, reach out to you during elections and be a source of information for the party. Their job is to support their parties’ candidates. Their job is not to think independently. If that is what they believe, they should never have run for a leadership position. My job as the chair is to ensure our party and its leaders support the candidate the Republicans chose in May.
But because these Libertarian candidates are Republicans, their friends who are leaders in the Republican Party have been put in a position to either stay a leader or renounce their position to support them. That is not a fair position to be placed.
As Chairman, I had to remove one precinct committeeman. She ran as a leader in the party, was elected by Republicans in her township to represent them and yet decided she should be able to support who she wants. That is not what the Republicans in her township elected her to do as a Republican precinct committeeman. And I did not put her in this position to choose. Her friend did.
And as for “party over person,” these Libertarian candidates have chosen to leave the Republican Party and run under the Libertarian platform. That is what it means to run under a party moniker. You are saying I am part of that party, and I support them. And if they are not supporting the Libertarian platform, what is that telling you about their integrity? They are willing to use whatever method to get on a ballot. That concerns me.
Party affiliation is one way to give you an idea of who that person is. It is to give you some idea the values that person holds. It is part of how you choose who to vote for, as are qualifications, integrity and past actions.
And people need to do their own research. Go to these websites and see which party you support. (lp.org, rnc.org, dnc.org)
Your choice should be someone with integrity, who’s honest and follows rules and aligns to your values — one who has been honest all along about who they are and what they believe, especially for a judge.
Instead, this election has become about people who chose not to run at the appropriate time and were looking for a way to get on the ballot at the last opportunity. It is telling the voters their choice in the Republican primary doesn’t matter — they made a mistake.
Your job as a voter is to pick a candidate that aligns with your beliefs, that has integrity, and the ability to follow rules and the law. That is what should matter.
For me, that is the Republican candidate, Jerry Smith.
Carole Snyder is chair of the Morgan County Republican Party.







